U.S. Supreme Court to Consider Citizenship Question on Census
Harris County brief is part of the record.
A court brief filed by Harris County Attorney Vince Ryan will be part of the record considered by the U.S. Supreme Court in a lawsuit seeking to prevent the U.S. Census Bureau from including a question about citizenship on the 2020 Census.
Ryan was joined in Harris County’s brief filed earlier this month by Fort Bend County Judge K.P. George and the City of Marfa. The brief asks the Supreme Court to affirm a district court judge’s ruling that the citizenship question cannot be included. The ruling came in a lawsuit filed against the Census Bureau by the State of New York.
“We join in the concerns expressed across the country that a question on citizenship will reduce the number of people participating in the 2020 Census,” said County Attorney Ryan. “This question will intimidate our immigrant population. We want everyone to participate—whether they are citizens or not.”
The brief states that the addition of the citizenship question to the 2020 Decennial Census will cause an undercount of each jurisdiction’s significant foreign-born population resulting in disproportionately low representation at the local, state, and federal levels along with corrupt data inadequate for effective governance. An undercount will also hurt the amount of federal dollars coming to these communities in programs based on population.
Harris County’s growth has always been driven by immigrants intertwined with new industries creating diverse economic engines for Texas and the country, Ryan points out in the brief. Neighboring suburban Fort Bend County has exploded in growth, diversity and affluence in the last few decades electing its first non-Anglo chief executive since the 1800s, immigrant K.P. George. While the tiny City of Marfa has not seen such explosive growth, it shares a high foreign-born population with Harris and Fort Bend at risk for a net undercount in the Decennial Census.
Ryan says the current intense climate of fear among immigrants makes it all the more likely that the net differential undercount will be more acute in Texas should the citizenship question be added to the census. In the past, as with the decades-long practice of using “white primaries” to disenfranchise African-American voters, the Supreme Court was the only source of protection to the constitutional rights of people wishing to engage in the civic sphere.
“Now, the Supreme Court’s intervention is needed again, to ensure the integrity of the data for representation and effective governance is protected,” County Attorney Ryan said. “Judge George, the City of Marfa and we agree with the New York district court’s finding that the undocumented and Hispanics will be disproportionately undercounted if the citizenship question is left in the Census.”
Ryan said this issue is so important that he has had his court brief translated into multiple languages so more Harris County residents can learn about this issue and what his office is doing to prevent the use of the citizenship question on the 2020 Census.
Summary of Brief in Various Languages